Want to order over the phone?
Call (424) 293-0474
Thank you for being with us!
We will call you back!
Want to order over the phone?
Call (424) 293-0474
08:00 - 17:00
08:00 - 17:00
08:00 - 17:00
00:00 - 17:00
00:00 - 17:00
This is the best restaurant in Monticello, the people who work there treat you like family,they give you a lot of fresh food,and it taste like real home cooked food,you can actually taste the love,come once,and you will be back !! We love nellys!!?
Awesome food!! The goat was delicious, almost melts in your mouth. The portions are huge. The staff is very friendly, and the place is very clean. I also got pork mofongo to go, also very delicious. Looks like this is going to be our favorite Dominican restaurant.
More5 stars when they start delivery service.
Good food! Good prices....but servers were not wearing masks or gloves.
Very, very tasty Dominican food. Everything is fresh. The pernil and chicken is deeeelish. Their rice and habichuelas also. The staff is very helpful and accommodating and polite. Huge servings and reasonably priced. Best food!
MoreAwful food, disgusting, same the one in Monticello, use to be great when was running by Nellie but since the sold the place the food is terrible, waste of money 🤮
MoreThe service is always good
Nice place to eat the food is excellent and the attande are very friendly and professional
MoreI simply love it ! The food is good and the people are friendly and pleasant. To me, it's great.
MoreFantastic...every thing is sooooooo good there ....one of my favorite places to eat ...their peppersteak and rice and beans is myfav..check them out you will not be disappointed
MoreGreat find while at the Kartrite Resort! Had the oxtail with white rice and it was legit! Staff is friendly!
MoreThe best you can find in Sullivan county NY. The staff are very nice. The food is very very good. Try Habichuelas con Dulce my favourite dessert.
MoreWaoo that is a great food thank you so much
Great place. Warm welcoming and great food. Nice price. If you are homesick or just want to taste Dominican or puertorrican food this is THE place.
MoreGood Dominican food and very friendly service.
Excellent food and excellent service with decent prices.
Great place to eat at,and the staff is very friendly and courteous. The food very good! Price is reasonable Nellys is highly recommend AAA+++++!
MoreIt's a 5 all day from ya main man daym drops lol. All jokes aside, the food was delicious I recommend the roast pork shoulder with a side of platanos and some rice and beans.. amazing!
MoreFood so good your taste buds will slap your momma. Bread pudding is to die for. You will need to order a to go plate before you leave that's how good the food is.
MoreAverage food! Very filling. But I really wished the waitress were more attentive and welcoming. Not a big fan of the “chipotle“ style concept.
MoreGood Good food.n nice people
Food is terrible since new people there i will not eat there anymore
Great food, great prices, very clean
Food was excellent very good
What I ordered to eat was ok,wasnt crazy about it
The best Dominican food around and great service.
The most authentic Spanish food north of Jersey City. So delicious. Mamey shake is killer, and the empanadas hit the spot!!
MoreGreat food and great people.
On Saturday evening my husband and I stopped in to Nellies because we wanted to bring a little something home that was different from our regular “easy dinners”. We remembered having empanadas at the Bagel Festival last summer and thought they were delicious. Unfortunately it was not so this time. We purchased 8 of them to take home. They had absolutely NO flavor! It tasted like a small amount of crumbled hamburger meat! Too much dough for the amount of filling! I feel like we wasted that $16.00. I would not recommend ordering them there! I must say that the 2 kinds of rice and beans that we purchased were very good.
MoreFood is ok they dont speak english too well so dont call in an order
This food is so good and prices are family friendly. The quality of it all is great.
MoreGreat food! and it's always ready no need to wait for someone to cook it here.
If you love Authentic Dominican food this is the place tio eat.
This was an amazing place to eat for reasonably priced delicious food but that was when the owner was Nelly. Sadly she's no longer there and the food's not as good the prices went up and the serving sizes decreased. It's no longer worth it but Nelly still has the bar around here.
Moredid not haye it just didnt like it
Don't be fooled by the way it looks. The food was amazing.
Good variety of food and excellent service
Excellent food!! Always so yummy
Treat yourself to some authentic Spanish cuisine. I dropped in town for a few days and was craving some real home style food. This place did not disappoint! Very tasty and reasonably priced. A gem out here in Monticello.
MoreLovely Dominican restaurant. Full of flavor and packed in great portions, the menu is straight out of the Dominican Republic. Great for curious foodies and trueblood Dominicans alike. Fantastic customer service as well, plus very clean!
MoreSmall quaint spot, excellent food!
Food very good but very salty
Great Dominican food at a great price. Stopped by with my wife after playing at the Catskills Casino. Awesome pork shoulder seasoning.
MoreHaaaaiiiii Dios mío 😮 love this place if your looking to eat right and fill your stomach right please go here money 💰 well spent for me lol !!!!
MoreGreat Dominican food, and also great attention
Great food better than expected.
We came to Nelly's on a whim, and it was wonderful! The food was full of flavor and not at all spicy. The roast pork and steak and onions we're delicious, especially with the yellow rice and beans. I highly recommend eating here!
MoreGreat place to try some Spanish food. The food is different but really good. I'm still trying the different types of food. The Modungo and Oxtail soups were very good.
MoreI’m Puerto Rican from Brooklyn. I hadn’t eaten Spanish food in 2 weeks while doing business in Liberty NY. I rolled the dice and made a 13 mile drive to Nelly’s. The food was exactly what I wanted. Hands down authentic Spanish food.
MoreThe food was great.it was nice an clean an the workers was professional
Delicious food! Great staff!